Wednesday, September 29, 2021

VIA's New Siemens Trainsets Through Kingston

Thanks to an early morning OS from fellow VIAphile Matt Soknacki, I headed out to Collins Bay to catch VIA's new Siemens Charger SC42 locomotive, Venture cars and cab car heading east from Toronto as CN train No 698 on September 29, 2021. Based on the train's speedy transit east from California, I knew it would be spritely. If not for the trains I encountered as I waited, it probably would have been sooner. Arriving at Belleville shortly after 1130, I was predicting 1215. The deadhead movement was running at track speed, with few delays en route aside from refuelling or recrewing. I took up my position on Kingston's Railfan Walking Trail, planning to take video on my point & shoot with tripod, and stills on cellphone.

VIA No 63 Eng 905 went west (above) and CN No 518 (below) with ailing CN 4789 and GMTX 2284 carrying about 10 KIMCO scrap loads on the south track. With only one engine online and 4789 not loading, the KIMCO cars were all the Little Engine That Could could handle up the hill at Mi 178. Their lift at Ernestown was made off the main to eliminate the need to lift the whole train up and out. CN No 271 took it easy with 518 occupying the south track just ahead!
Five hours from Sarnia to Toronto, with a normal freight train transit time of 10 hours. Only 24 hours from Chicago. And we thought only hogs could clear That Toddlin' Town without changing trains! CN 8869 had taken over at Battle Creek, MI and departed Flint at 2315 on Tuesday night. Elmer Ogden's  granddaughter was called for the train out of Toronto at 0800. CN 5638-2204 led CN No 271 at 1238 coming up on CN No 518 lifting at Ernestown, taken from the south side of Bath Road (below). I could not scan the train - I had to keep my eyes on the wheels of cars on CN No 271, concerned that 698 might slip by. Worse than not getting a photo would have been not knowing the short train had sneaked by me, obscured by the all-encompassing auto racks! 
VIA No 40 was eastbound on the north track before 698 appeared on its block, also on the north track. (CN No 368 was following 698.) A break in road traffic and ETU squawks alerted me to 698's presence in time for me to cross Bath Road with tripod and all without being flattened.
Siemens Cinema! Watch my my Youtube video of 698.

The consist: locomotive 2200, Business Class/Classe Affaires cars 2600 and 2700, coaches 2800 and 2900, cab car 2300 (with no cab car cab-side numbers) and locomotive 2201.   Youtube video (33:33 mark) here. Business Class car 2700 is at right (below). Notice the Business Class cars have slightly darker grey paint. Good luck to railfans trying to find the car numbers on these CTC (Caved-in Tin Can) cars!

The train continued east to Montreal. Railfan reports: Whitby 0915, Darlington 0945, Clarke 1000, Belleville 1130, Kingston 1300, Prescott 1425, Cornwall 1525, Dorval 1630. Since the Business Class lounge at Ottawa station was just reopened, I can't imagine the new trainset will spend much time in Montreal before heading to Ottawa for a photo op with a plethora of politicos.

This preview of new VIA Rail Canada technology cast my mind back to the debut of the LRC! VIA quickly posted this photo (by David McCormack) sans CN 8869 at VIA's Montreal Maintenance Centre. Reporting marks SIIX 2200 and classification SC-42 showing. They've ordered 32 of the new consists. CN 8869 returned west on a more pedestrian assignment, CN No 369 about 24 hours later, accompanied by 'BC Rail' 4648 in the blue scheme.

SETS DELIVERED SO FAR

I'll endeavour to keep a running total of sets delivered showing the date each set travelled through Kingston, locomotive and cab car numbers. Interestingly, since locomotive 2201 was delivered coupled to Set 1, each set's cars' last numeral matches the cab car's, not the locomotive's. While it may have been intended for each last numeral to match every part of the Set, this has not been the case, except for Set 1.
  • Set 1: Sep 29/21 2200*-2300 (and 2201)
  • Set 2: Aug 6/22 2202-2301
  • Set 3: Jan 30/23 2203-2302
  • Set 4: Apr 19/23 2204-2303
  • Set 5: Jun 6/23 2205-2304
  • Set 6: Jul 10/23 2206-2305
  • Set 7: Aug 5/23 2207-2306
  • Set 8: Sep 5/23 2208-2307
  • Set 9: Oct 7/23 2209-2308
  • Set 10: Nov 9/23 no loco-2309*
  • Set 11: Dec 13/23 2210-2310**
  • Set 12: Jan 12/24 2211-2311
  • Set 13: Feb 18/24 2212-2312
  • Set 14: Mar 17/24 2213-2313
  • Set 15: Apr 17/24 2214-2314
  • Set 16: May 8/24 2215-2315
  • Set 17: Jun 1/24 2216-2316
  • Set 18: Jun 26/24 2218-2317 yellow!
  • Set 19: Aug 2/24 2219-2318***
  • Set 20: Aug 2/24 2220-2319***
  • Set 21: Sep 15/24 2217-2320****
  • Set 22: Sep 15/24 2221-2321****
  • Set 23: Oct 5/24 2222-2322
  • Set 24: Nov 18/24 2223-2323*****
  • Set 25: Nov 18/24 2224-2324 *****
*2200/2309 mated as of first test run west from MMC April 29, 2024.
**note new correlation of last two digits of delivered sets until Set 17, then again from Set 23.
***delivered together; locomotive 2217 was still at Siemens California plant.
****delivered together.
*****delivered together.

-2303 and 2313 no cab-car side numbers ( *visible on conductor's side on 2313, 2303 still missing as of Sep 1/2024)
-2306 no VIA nose logo (restored by July 2024)

Lots o' video links of Set 1:

As of January, 2024 and with the delivery of the twelfth Siemens Venture set, I've split this post, with deliveries here and Siemens Venture sets in service here.
[My original language - Until a separate post is required, I'll endeavour to keep track of subsequent Siemens set delivery progress below, along with other implementation updates and test runs]

SET 2: UP 5275 led Set 2 east, OS Kingston 0300 on Saturday, August 6, 2022. A full set of six units by VIA 2202 with cab coach 2301 on the tail-end. West of Sarnia symbolled P623, then L533 east of there. Bayview at 2025 August 5, Belleville 0235 August 6, Coteau 0600. 

SET 3: UP 5736 led Set 3 east out of Sacramento, CA. A full set of six units behind SIIX 2203, cars ending in -02, cab car 2302. Slow progress, with UP 6279 leading through Rochelle, IL on January 28, 2023. CN 3061 took over at Battle Creek, down the Kingston Sub eastward as train P276 on the morning of January 30, 13 days after starting its journey, making it here from Sarnia in eight hours. At Belleville (below - image courtesy Railstream, LLC):
SET 4: UP 8686 led Set 4 (leader 2204/cab car 2303 with no cab car cab-side numbers!) east, through Nebraska on April 16, 2023; Chicago on April 18; Lansing MI early on April 19; now symbolled P276 led by CN 3087; Sarnia 1330; Toronto around suppertime, then Montreal at 0700 April 20. There was some drama around Belleville when 3087 was found to have low water and CN 2324 from a westbound was to be donated.

SET 5: UP 7902 is leading Set 5 (leader 2205/cab car 2304) with three Amtrak Midwest Venture cars tagging along, is heading east across Nevada on June 1; Kearney NE on the evening of June 2, Homewood IL on June 4 evening, Griffith IN webcam at 1900 behind CN 8961 (below), the Amtrak cars not in the consist - predicted Battle Creek MI by 0500 as symbol P276 June 5, Toronto in the evening of June 5, passed through Kingston 0030 on June 6. I'm going to officially call them Venture consists, not Siemens consists from now on!

SET 6: UP 6519 departed California with Set 6 (leader 2206, cab-car 2305) July 6, reaching Cheyenne, WY July 8, Rochelle IL July 9, Durand MI at 0700 as CN P276 Eng 8012 and Bayview Junction at 1530 July 10, Oshawa 1840 before being held at Belleville 3 hours due to crew-ordering problems, through Kingston at 2240 on its way to a Montreal early on July 11.

SET 7: UP 3093 leading Set 7 (leader 2207, cab-car 2306 with no VIA logo on nose), through Wyoming and into Iowa August 2-3; Wheaton IL evening of August 3; into Indiana August 4; as CN No P276 Engs 5675-8956 London 0900 August 5; Georgetown 1130; Port Hope 1420; Kingston 1700 (below); Brockville 1755. Video at Kingston.
SET 8: UP 6263 (thanks, Zackery Boyd) led Set 8 (leader 2208, cab-car 2307), as CN No P276 Engs 5688-3155 (elephant-style) Sept.5 OS Brantford 0440, Oshawa 0730, Belleville 1040, Kingston 1135, Coteau 1450.  
SET 9: UP 8178 led Set 9 (above - leader 2209/cab-car 2308), through Kearney, NE at 0900 on October 5. As CN No P276 through Flint, MI at 2300 October 6, with no plan to replace the UP unit with a CN unit. OS Aldershot 0430; Snider 0630; Liverpool 0900; Oshawa 0920; Darlington 0925; 1115 Belleville; 1155 Kingston; Brockville 1250; Dorval 1500. (UP 8178 was sent back on October 8's auto rack train CN No 271.)

SET 10: UP 5476 led Set 10 (cab-car 2309 but NO LOCOMOTIVE possibly to be mated to 2200 or 2201/cab-car 2300), through Auburn, CA on October 31. Nebraska Nov 2 evening (above - Virtual Railfan webcam image); Rochelle noon November 3; Charlotte, MI 0500; Flint 0900; as CN No P276 still led by UP 5476; Sarnia 1100 delayed there by brake/mechanical issues, tied down 1355, until at least November 5 and leader replaced with CN 2243; planned trip was 14 hours Sarnia-Taschereau. 
Restart! Set 10 through Ingersoll November 9 1245; London 1530; Kingston around 2130 behind CN 2673. Video (44:00 mark). Rob McClintock kindly shared this photo of the cab-less tail-end of Set 10 on arrival at Sarnia: 
As many railfans had longed for, VIA 2200 was added to locomotive-less Set 10 and made a test run west over the CN Kingston Sub on the afternoon of April 29, 2024, symbolized CN P267 (possibly 627)! On May 1, Set 10 was in service as VIA No 61/46.

SET 11: (leader 2210/cab-car 2310 - first synchronized numbered set!) through Laramie, WY on Sunday morning, Dec.10 behind UP 8649; Kearney NE that evening; Rochelle, IL Dec.11 at 1400; Valparaiso, IN 0600 Dec.12; Battle Creek, MI 0900-1100+; Port Huron, MI 1935; Paris Jct 0140 Dec.13; Belleville 0630-0800+; Kingston 0845:
UP 8649 returned west the next day on CN auto rack empty train CN No 271.
Here are two views of Set 11 from the Charlotte, MI webcam. Thanks to Jesse McLaughlin for the link. I kept these because it appeared Set 11 would pass here nocturnally!
SET 12: Reported already in Ontario Jan. 12/24 CN P276 (leader 2211/cab-car 2311) by UP 2598 Sarnia at 0900; Paris Jct. 1225; Aldershot 1330; through Kingston at 1930. (Set 12 made a run to London on March 11.)

No deliveries in February yet, so here's an interlude - three photos from the Trackside Treasure collection of a Venture set at MMC with the cab-car removed:
The red is grease. I can't account for the kindling wood, however!

SET 13: (Leader 2212/cab-car 2312) reportedly lifted by UP 6628 from Siemens in California Feb.13; through Kearney NE at 1730 Fri. Feb.16; Charlotte MI Sat. Feb 17 at 1411, Flint at 1530, Sarnia 1700-2000; CN P276 then Equipment Move 4142 delivered to TMC (that's a first!) by the UP unit at 0200 Feb.18. Excellent photos kindly shared by Lion Liu (below). It's there for training and because space is tight due to already-stored sets and construction at MMC. Set 13 reportedly coupled to VIA 901 as an HEP source at TMC on Feb. 21. Still at TMC as of April 19/24, heading east as VIA No 636 on April 25; testing from Ottawa to Montreal via Brockville as "No 668" May 7.
SET 14: (leader 2213/cab-car 2313 has no cab side numbers!) led by UP 5041 through Mishawaka IN at 1815 Mar.16; Battle Creek, MI 2200; still in Port Huron 0300; arr Sarnia 1050 Sun Mar 17/24; London 1310; Tansley on Halton Sub 1600; Belleville 2130; Kingston 2300, symbolled CN P276. Later reported entering service on May 4 on VIA No 24.

SET 15 (leader 2214/cab car 2314) led by UP 5875 (UP=Unwashed Power!) left Siemens' California plant 0400 Sunday April 14. Terry Allan kindly shared this image from the Roseville, CA webcam (below) and the train had two Amtrak grey/red Siemens cars on the tail-end; UP 5875 'died' and was replaced by CN 8955 at Homewood, IL early Tues. Apr. 16; arriving Battle Creek 0710; Charlotte MI 1130; approaching Flint 1400; Sarnia 1500; London 2000; Mac Yard 2300, Kingston 0300 then MMC 0630, symbolled CN P276.
Crew change at Snider behind CN 8955 - photo kindly shared by Lion Liu:
SET 16: (Leader 2215/cab car 2315) led by UP 7048 through North Platte, NE May 5; through Iowa and Illinois evening of May 6; CN P276 planned 0600 May 7, Homewood, IL; East Lansing, MI 0945 May 7 behind CN 8809; Sarnia 1600; London 1740; Kingston 0200 May 8, Montreal 0500.

SET 17 (Leader 2216/cab car 2316) led by UP 7839 through Rochelle, IL (below) 1132 CDTMay 31; Blue Island, IL 1800, planned 2130 Homewood as CN P276. UP unit removed in Battle Creek, MI replaced by CN 2334; June 1 ETA Sarnia 0830; 1415 Bayview Jct; Oshawa 1800; Kingston 2000 thence Montreal.
SET 18 (Leader 2218/cab car 2317) led by UP 6446 through Utah (screenshot below) on the afternoon of June 22, with two Amtrak Midwest cars tagging along. There goes our loco/cab-car numerical correlation again! A Turbo-inspired scheme as suggested by VIA employees. Then Denver, CO Sun. June 23 a.m., Cheyenne, WY p.m.; Rochelle, IL June 24 1400; Markham, IL at midnight as P276; Tues June 25 Charlotte, MI 0800; Lansing 0820; with a CN 5764 ahead of UP 6446; Port Huron at noon; Sarnia 1445; Woodstock 1630; Cobourg 2130; Kingston 2345; Dorval 0230. 
Interestingly, the coach next to the cab car - 2817 - is also marked "Business Class" on the left side (considering the locomotive as the front) along with the expected 2617 and 2717 next to the locomotive.  Only coach 2917 and cab car 2317 are not marked as Business Class (reported by Lance Gleich). We've seen earlier Sets arrive with UP or CN power, and with two CN units, but this is the first with UP and CN power! Due to the ongoing nocturnal photo-unfriendly deliveries, Stephen Gardiner kindly shared his photos of Set 18's delivery train at CN Humber. The large white VIA is mercifully unseen behind a trackside tree (below). 
A July 10 media availability, VIA christened Set 18 'Lumi'. "Short for luminosity, Lumi is a one-of-a-kind yellow train that will be in service by the end of August. Just like our other new trains, a series of tests need to be performed before going into service: Lumi’s tests will start within the next couple of days between Ottawa and MontrĂ©al, so be on the lookout!"

SET 19: (Leader 2219/cab car 2318) led by UP 9596 along with....
SET 20: (Leader 2220/cab car 2319)
Both sets together. Roseville, CA afternoon of Mon. July 29; Kearney, NE at 1420 Wed. July 31; Aug. 1 Clinton, IA 0525; Rochelle, IL 0800CDT ; Blue Island, IL 1635; Homewood 1700 with CN 2293 leading (planned Sarnia 0630) Aug 2; Griffith, IN 2200; Aug 2 London 1130; Silver on the Halton Sub 1400; Pickering 1655; Belleville 1900-1945 waiting for recrew; Kingston 2110. (Locomotive 2217 still at Siemens plant.) David McCormack kindly shared one of his photos from his day-long pursuit of the unique double delivery that ranged from Bayview to Belleville. Curving eastbound at Lovekin:
SET 21: (Leader 2217/cab car 2320) led by UP 5394 along with....
SET 22: (Leader 2221/cab car 2321)
Both sets together. Roseville, CA September 10 at 1700 PDT; Kearney, NE Thurs. Sept. 12 at 1945CDT; Rochelle, IL Sept.13 at 1530CDT; Blue Island, IL at 2100CDT; departed Homewood, IL 0500 Sept.14 now with CN 3077; Battle Creek, MI 1250; Lansing, MI 1350; Flint, MI 1445; Port Huron, MI 1800-1830; Sarnia 1840-1900; Strathroy 1940; Brantford 2130; Oakville 2230; Toronto (Snider) 0001 Sat. Sept.14; Clarke 0130; Kingston 0440; Montreal (Turcot) 0740 - yet another nocturnal Kingston Sub delivery. Video capture at Rochelle at 1732 from Virtual Railfan LIVE webcam:
SET 23: (Leader 2222/cab car 2322 - no photo) led by UP 6146 passed Kearney, NE at 2027 Wed Oct 2; expected to depart Homewood Yard/Markham, IL Oct 4 1015 waited for crew until 2000 with CN 2656 leader; South Bend, IN at 1830; Imlay City, MI at 0545 October 5; Paris Jct 1025; some delays due to York Sub detours; Belleville 1730-1915; Kingston 2010. Nocturnalness continues!

SET 24: Leader 2223/cab car 2323) led by UP 5817 along with...
SET 25: Leader 2224/cab car 2324 was seen outside the Siemens plant on Nov.11)
Both sets together (Set 25 first) along with locomotive allo exo 1400 through Boone, IA Nov. 15 at 1155 CST; Charlotte, MI 1645 with CN 8014 now leading; Lansing, MI 1715; Flint, MI 1750; Mishawaka (near South Bend), IN afternoon 275 miles from Sarnia, shown in two videos: behind CN 8014 and another view; arrival Sarnia 2000, staged due to running 'ahead of schedule', planned departure from Sarnia Nov. 17 at 1400; departed Sarnia 1530, triggered hotbox detector at Mile 54.5 Strathroy Sub with 4 hot axles all from engine 2224 due to handbrakes couldn’t be fully released, inspected and re-released the handbrakes, back on move at 1630 (1'55" behind schedule), Siemens contractor to inspect at London; London 1750; Bayview Jct 1940; Snider West 2200; Belleville 0140 Nov. 18; Kingston 0230.
Video captures from Live Railcam: Boone Iowa - Trains On Demand (below). 

Running extra...

It's a little unusual to find two contemporary, not retro, posts on Trackside Treasure. Ripped from the headlines of today! I can't help myself. These two recent railway-related events just happened to occur in and around Kingston. To observe each one, I had an hour to spare during my grandson's midday naptime. So conveniently-scheduled!

This is going to take some getting used to: VIA getting new equipment! Not recycled, not refurbished, not second-hand. And a poorly-kept secret, photographed and video'd by railfans across North America and along CN's Kingston Sub. I'm sure if 698's crew had been playing Railfan Bingo, they could have won with a Full Card! Malcolm! Andre! Paul! Zack! Of course the middle spot on the card would be decorated with crossbucks!

Speaking of poorly-kept secrets, CP 8757 makes its debut today, mysteriously wrapped and not-so-surreptitiously transported to Calgary (the wrap blew off in the wilds of Alberta!) in honour of the first National Day for Truth and Reconciliation:

Thursday, September 23, 2021

CN Derailment at Amherst View, September 2021

 

I was awake for a mere 20 minutes on Wednesday, September 22 and preparing for the arrival of our grandson for the day when the phone rang. It was my son notifying me of a CN derailment in Amherst View at the foot of the Loyalist Township water tower there. This sports field is the very site at which my railfanning career began, so I tuned into the online coverage right away. Many early-morning VIA trains never left their cities of origin and CN had freights staged on both sides of the derailment, which occurred around 0600. It's amazing how one car can bring the country's busiest line to a screeching halt. [My kingdom for a nail! - see below]
I nipped out and made my way to the site around 1140 during our grandson's nap. (Don't worry, his grandmother was at home keeping an eye on him!) Most of the local Twittersphere, alerted to the derailment around 0600 by the Ontario Provincial Police, was interested in which level crossings were blocked on their way to work. Coronation Boulevard, just to the east was blocked mainly for putting on hi-rail equipment, opened to traffic at 0830. I wanted to know more - train ID, circumstances, plans for clean-up and other nuts-and-bolts information! Trackside Treasure inquisitive minds need to know! This John Wilson photo was posted to Twitter:
The train was CN No 368, that left CN's Toronto MacMillan Yard for Montreal at 2300 hours on September 21. The train was 162 cars in length, and the rear part still remaining at the site, on the south track, was empty paper/lumber boxcars and centrebeam flat cars. This area is known for slack action and a see-saw profile. A train full of empties is a challenge here. I arrived at the sports field via Fairfield Boulevard, staying clear of the mass of CN vehicles on both sides of Coronation Boulevard!
Reports of a single derailed car did not mention that it was TBOX 660669. It was now considerably more perpendicular to the roadbed than in the Twitter photo! The east end had been rerailed, and news reports indicate it was loaded with tomato paste! Two excavators were working on its west end. The east-end drawbar was found an estimated three carlengths away, between the rails.
CN's road-rail crane (above) and Belleville road repair truck (below) were on the north and south tracks, respectively. Notice the new ties needed for the estimated 200 feet of torn-up track structure, dropped off by the local section forces from a boom-equipped hi-rail truck.
Steadying the TBOX with a hi-rail Railavator brought to Coronation Boulevard on a float truck, and pulling out parts of the running gear:

Progress was relatively swift. Foreman Brent was in charge of the site, and Signal Maintainer Leonard released the north crossing at Coronation Boulevard just to the east at 1230. CN No 518 was light power; CN 5783-8825 had come east from Belleville via Ernestown around 0920. They were ready to take the tail-end of the train west to Belleville yard. I believe the TBOX and its adjacent boxcar were set out in Millhaven. (The head-end had continued east toward its destination.) They coupled on, having waited a few carlengths west of the tail-end at Mile 183:
The above photo is taken from a well-worn path across the tracks in five seconds. 
The locomotives were NOT moving!

It was a busy day for the Rail Traffic Controller in Edmonton (No Problem!) and local section forces. Train movements through the site:

  • CN No 271, empty auto racks, halted near Queens at 0800, was recrewed and OS 1500 past the site. It reached Doncaster at 2200.
  • CN No 121, Halifax-Toronto intermodal, stopped near Leeds around 0900, OS 1600. Having left Turcot at 2200 on September 21, it reached BIT 24 hours later!
  • VIA No 40 was more or less on time, and was the first train through the site, heading east from Ernestown past No 518, after the north track was released at 1230.
  • VIA Nos 65 and 64 were through next.
  • CN No 731's westward progress was expedited due to its crew being short on time, 848 axles OS 1450. Interestingly, it passed Aldershot at 2115.
  • VIA No 42 was the first train through the south track. There was a 10 mph restriction on this track between Mi 183-182.
  • VIA No 47 was next on the north track.
  • CN No 120 with 624 axles, OS 1615. Nos 120/121 are normally nocturnal!
  • CN No 109 was making its way west at Kings around 1700.
  • CN No 377 and 376 were approaching, plus the regular evening VIA trains were on their way.
I can recall two other derailments in this area. In March, 1980 this train also derailed some boxcars at the sports field. On August 1, 2008 seven cars of corn derailed, east of the 1980 site. As my brother wryly noted, perhaps such slack-generated derailments have been occurring in this hog's-back profile since the days of the Grand Trunk Railway! Here is your humble blogger with a broken knuckle discovery nearby in spring, 1979. (L.C. Gagnon photo - his late afternoon shadow visible at left.) Also, note the clean and clear right-of-way with two white wooden whistle posts, mileboard on telegraph pole, and white concrete milepost visible in the distance:

Running extra...

I hope you voted and that your vote counted in Monday's election. Turnout was brisk despite Canadians generally grumbling about government. I found poll workers knowledgeable and helpful. And good news - I haven't heard about anyone storming our Parliament to overturn the results!

This unattributed saying "For Want of a Nail", looms large in terms of little things becoming Brobdingnagian: 
For want of a nail the shoe was lost;
For want of a shoe the horse was lost;
For want of a horse the battle was lost;
For the failure of battle the kingdom was lost—
All for the want of a horse-shoe nail.

Friday, September 17, 2021

Postscript: CN Auto-With-You Survey

CN's Auto-With-You service was operated from 1972 until the VIA era began in 1976. Between 1967 and 1972, CN had received requests from passengers to travel with their own automobiles, based on similar service in Europe. Another precedent was the Washington-Florida Auto-Train service initiated in 1971. CN's Super Continental blasts through Concord, ON in these undated photos kindly shared by John Wallington, with a 57-foot auto transporter in passenger colours bringing up the markers:
This post is actually a postscript to an earlier post on CN Car-Go-Rail and Auto-With-You services. Car-Go-Rail was not attractive to passengers because of its limited service and schedule, and the passengers were without their auto while it was in transit. CN experimented with Auto-With-You service on train Nos 3 and 4 between Toronto and Edmonton. There was daily service with six autos per train. The passengers travelled aboard the same train. Passengers delivered their auto four hours prior to departure, with the auto made available soon after arrival in Toronto or Edmonton. 
In this 1973 online auction site photo, CN 8516 has two 57-foot auto transporters at the loading area at the west end of Toronto Union Station, by the CN Express building:
CN commissioned a survey among Auto-With-You users, the results of which were published in September, 1972. Of the 192 questionnaires mailed to Canadian and American users of the service, 112 were returned, giving a 60% return rate. These were peak-season passengers, and the survey was returned in a pre-addressed, postage-paid envelope to encourage participation. Highlights of the survey results:
  • 90% of the respondents travelled by CN due to the service being provided. If it had not been available, two-thirds would have driven and 18% per cent would have flown or used the bus.
  • 29% said they would have rented a car otherwise
  • 80% were on vacation
  • 85% of the trips were one-way, only 15% were round-trips
  • 13% were moving to a new home
  • 5% said their employer paid the fare for them

What did passengers think about the service?
  • 50% were completedly satisfied, mentioning careful handling of their autos and courteous employees
  • 35% thought the service was expensive
  • 90% also booked sleeping car space, with the remainder only travelling in coach because sleeping car space was not available

Why did passengers use Auto-With-You?
  • 58% said it saved them the drive
  • 30% said it was faster than driving
  • 18% would not have driven that far

Unfavourable comments about Auto-With-You:
  • 13% experienced delays in car delivery
  • 4% reported damage to their auto
  • 9% said employees were not knowledgeable about the plan

Unfavourable comments about their trip aboard CN:
  • 7% thought CN needed dome cars, (like CP?!)
  • 3% said their sleeping accommodation was too cramped
  • 4% complained of insufficient ventilation
  • 3% mentioned train delays
  • 6% did not find the food satisfactory

What about the cost?
  • 54% said the cost of shipping their auto was reasonable, 35% said it was expensive
  • 68% said tickets were reasonable, 14% said they were expensive

What about the prospect of using open auto racks?
  • 50% would ship in an open auto rack, but only if CN were responsible for damages!
  • Of those who would not ship in open auto rack, 78% said their auto not be safe from inclement weather or vandalism
  • 13% said their auto would not be secure
  • 31% said their auto would get too dirty
These results give us contemporary reaction to CN's revolutionary service, perhaps pointing to some reasons why it was not continued!

Running extra...

I finished two books recently. Yep, got 'em both coloured. Seriously though, I actually read two books. A rare ramble into fiction for me, with a re-read of Nicholas Monsarrat's two-years-in-the-making The Cruel Sea, telling the story of a corvette (non-sports car corvette!). Also, Mission Thrift Store dollar purchase of Alec Ross' 1986 Coke Stop in Emo. These two make me want to stay on dry land, away from U-boats and rapids, respectively!

Kudos to author Ross for using the adjective "Brobdingnagian" at one point in his saga. His usage loomed large for me. In fact it was gigantic! Hugely impressive. 

Running extra...Extra Election Edition!

Riding home from Toronto to Kingston one evening during the Stephen Harper reign, an elderly couple with special needs was seated apart in the Business Class car. They spoke to the attendant who told them he'd see what he could do. Then, a passenger boarded at Oshawa and was seated behind me in the single seat row of 2+1 seating. Overhearing the seniors' plight, he quickly volunteered to switch seats, giving them two seats together. After they switched, the couple expressed their thanks and talked to the fellow as dinner service started. The Oshawa passenger volunteered that he was going to Ottawa. He was going there for a veterans' event. They clearly had no idea who he was. I recognized him as Erin O'Toole, the then-Minister of Veterans Affairs, though he didn't tell them that. As I disembarked at Kingston, I briefly told him 'thanks' for making those elderly folks' trip much more enjoyable. I don't care about your or my political stripe, but integrity is doing the right thing - especially when no-one is watching. (Well, I was.)

Speaking of gigantic, be sure to vote in this Monday's election. In fact, vote early and often. You can even bring your own pen or pencil! No crayons. Thousands of our forebears died to build and preserve Canada, and while it's eminently Canadian to sit and grouse about our government, not voting seems un-Canadian. This election will not be rigged. Please vote for the party of your choice. The results for PM may actually take until the AM, so be patient.