Saturday, April 6, 2024

Kingston & Pembroke Stations

Even though there's a comprehensive Kingston & Pembroke (K&P) website, the stations (later CP) in Frontenac County have rarely been shown in sequence. In this final post in this four-post series, pictured south to north are: Kingston, Glenvale, Murvale, Harrowsmith, Sigsworth (flag stop), Hartington, Verona, Godfrey. Farther north were: Hinchinbrooke, Parham, Olden, Sharbot Lake, Oso, Clarendon, Mississippi and Snow Road. (Photos in this post posted to Facebook Vintage Kingston Group unless otherwise noted.)  

The K&P's first station in Kingston was at Place d'Armes and Ontario Street, shown as the Frontenac Lumber and Coal Co., with the original engine house is just visible at right (top photo - Queen's University Archives, Kingston Picture Collection, V23.6 IndB Frontenac Lumber). The building was dismantled in 1924.

The much better-known K&P station that still stands is across Ontario Street from City Hall. (Queen's University Archives, Hazelgrove Slide Collection, V020-5-534) shown on April 8, 1962:

Glenvale 

Murvale in October, 1970  (Queen's University Archives, George Lilley Fonds, V25.5-39-108)
Darcy Laframboise finds some interesting items at Murvale with a metal detector. 
Harrowsmith, 1960 
Harrowsmith was moved across the tracks to Meeks lumber yard in 1964, demolished in 1999.
Hartington, 1948 (Queen's University Archives, George Lilley Aerial Photographs, V25.6-1-6-35)
Note that the nation track has been stub-ended, with a plank required to reach the main track from the station wooden platform. Before a station was built at Hartington, Sigsworth flag-stop on the Petworth Road was a grain-shipping point for the area as early as 1887.

Verona in October, 1970 (Queen's University Archives, George Lilley Fonds, V25.5-39-109)
Verona, 1910 
 
George Lilley took several angles during his visit, some artistic.



Godfrey, undated 

Running extra...
Every other news story this weekend seems to be eclipsed by....well, the eclipse. Since we're on the path of totality here in Kingston, the city has predicted up to 500,000 may visit to see what Kingston looks like in the dark. 
A terrible confluence of construction consternation coincided with dark humour this week as the LaSalle Causeway, courtesy of Public Services and Procurement Canada and its contractor, was rendered useless until repaired. Here's a retrospective look before the major support member under the counterweight was bent, pending counterweight removal and repair. 

Monday, April 1, 2024

Kingston & Pembroke Facilities in Kingston

This is the third in a five-post series on the Kingston & Pembroke Railway. This post deals with the buildings and facilities that the K&P, and later CP, inhabited in Kingston. Its terminus was across Ontario Street from Kingston City Hall (top photo - Queen's University Archives, George Lilley Aerial Photographs, V25.6-10-7).

DOWNTOWN TRACKAGE ON ONTARIO STREET

Its initial request to build on Fort Frontenac lands was refused, so the K&P instead settled on Place d’Armes in 1873. Its principal address in Kingston was listed as Place d’Armes in 1885, and the original station of the K&P in Kingston was built there (three-storey building, centre of 1920 photo below, with engine house visible at bottom right). The site had previously been used by the military in Kingston as a 'fuel yard'. The station became the office building for the Frontenac Lumber & Coal Company. A spur was later laid crossing Ontario Street to serve the Montreal Transportation Company grain elevator. A small two-stall engine house was built nearby, in use between 1877 and 1883, and the track continued to North Street. 
In 1929, CP’s Kingston ticket, express freight and steamship office was at 180 Wellington Street. Its freight offices were at the foot of Clarence Street and passenger station was listed as being opposite City Hall. The track closest to the station was considered the mainline, with the adjacent track serving as an engine run-around track. The next tracks received perishable shipments such as refrigerator cars for Toye’s Wholesale or newsprint for the Whig-Standard. The next two tracks held cars spotted for the freight shed, with CN’s track to the locomotive plant and shipyards at waterside.  The  plan below includes the Market Battery, then only a memory. 

Although the K&P had negotiated running rights with the GTR from River Street to near Brock and Ontario Streets in 1886, it requested and was approved construction of its own track between Brock Street and the K&P passenger station across from City Hall. A February, 1957 lake view shows freight cars on the CN and CP trackage at water's edge, and the CP freight station and sheds (below - Queen's University Archives, George Lilley Fonds, V25.5-51-37-307-1). A switchman’s wooden shanty north of Barrack Street and west of Ontario Street housed a CN flagman to cover CP movements across CN even into the early 1960’s (circled in yellow in photo above).  
The Ontario Street station, showing its awning between the baggage shed and the station. The Richardson No 1 elevator is visible at far left. Undated, pre-1941 with streetcar tracks apparently still in Ontario Street (Trackside Treasure collection):
Here's a different angle, from the Wolfe Island ferry dock in July, 1963 (Queen's University Archives, Kingston Whig-Standard Fonds, V142.1-24) with CLC in the distance at left:

ONTARIO STREET PASSENGER STATION AND FREIGHT STATION 

Built in 1885 at a cost of $12,000 and measuring 65 x 24 feet, the stone station included stone from the demolished Market Battery nearby. Designed by William Newlands, main floor wider central curved windows as well as other curved windows were crowned with coloured art glass fanlights. The bellcast roof featured six gabled dormers and a patterned slate covering topped by iron fringework. The interior was finished in natural woods. A 125-foot covered passageway led to the station baggage room. Drawings and descriptions published in a December 10, 1886 edition of the Whig (below) and both buildings were finished and occupied by the following July.
After the end of passenger service, the baggage room is being demolished on February 29, 1960 (below - Queen's University Archives, George Lilley Fonds, V25.5-26-99)
In the 1920’s, large floral CPR lettering was part of the decorative station gardens. The station is still in use as Kingston’s Visitor Information Centre.

From 1917 to 1923, perennial plans for the construction of CP freight sheds on Place d'Armes near the then-CN, ex-GTR freight sheds built in 1912, were a constant source of discussion in the city. The desire was to eliminate several street crossings by CP trains serving the freight sheds: Brock, Princess and Queen. CP's freight station/shed remained closer to the lake, thought its offices were consumed by fire on December 29, 1939 as shown in this Whig clipping:
The freight sheds were demolished in 1966, making way for Confederation Park in time for Canada's Centennial. Demolition is underway on July 21, 1966 (two photos below - Queen's University Archives, Kingston Whig-Standard Fonds V142.3-196). The freight sheds were vacated on July 8 of that year, and the last CP yard tracks removed. The freight shed was occupied by some local teen coffee-house denizens after their Brock Street location was no longer available in the interim for a few days.
Almost gone, CN boxcars nearby. 

PLACE D'ARMES FREIGHT YARD

A 1964 aerial view (below - CP lead in green) after crossing Ontario Street on the 0.1-mile (J)oint section with CN, CP's trackage skirted the coal yards at Place d'Armes, where CP had a team track and (I)intermodal piggyback ramp. Passing through Anglin's lumber yard, Canadian Dredge & Dock, and (N)orth Street before heading farther north, parallel to CN. (Queen's University Archives, Kingston Whig-Standard Fonds, V142.1-60)
A road-level view of the intermodal tracks, taken on April 7, 1967 during work on the Lasalle Causeway (Queen's University Archives, Kingston Whig-Standard Fonds, V142.4-128)

FOOT OF NORTH STREET ROUNDHOUSE AND FREIGHT YARD

Eleven acres of what was deemed swamp were filled in to provide land for the K&P yard, roundhouse and turntable along the Inner Harbour, usually referred to as being at the 'foot of North Street'. The track then crossed the Grand Trunk Railway (GTR) at a diamond crossing protected by semaphore signals at River Street. 

The mixed train’s passenger cars were taken to the roundhouse upon arrival, where the baggage car was turned on the turntable and recoupled to the coach for the next day’s trip north. The steam locomotive was left at the ash pit for maintenance by the North Street roundhouse crew. 
In its hey-day, the five-stall roundhouse made running repairs to up to four steam locomotives, five coaches and up to 20 freight cars with the labour of only a few men. In 1948 for instance, locomotive foreman H.R. Davis did greasing, oiling, watering and emergency coaling. Regular coaling was done at Tichborne. Car inspector A.A. Potter supplied ice and water for coaches, filling Pintsch gas lamp tanks and tending car stoves. Joseph Harten was labourer and Thomas Roberts, employed at the Kingston roundhouse for 32 years, covered the night shift. A steam boiler kept coaches warm in the yard. CPR 459 emerges from a roundhouse stall onto the turntable on February 13, 1948 (above - Queen's University Archives, George Lilley Fonds, V25.5-1-392). 

The question of when the roundhouse and turntable were installed is perplexing. It's shown on an 1892-1904 fire insurance map. A May 1, 1896 drawing showing Ordnance Land and location of the K&P roundhouse (Library and Archives Canada):
 Mel Easton's book reports the date '1917' scratched into some concrete at the site. There are several incidents from 1909 to 1913 (though none before reported in the newspapers) at the K&P roundhouse: a worker injury, weed-clearing, small fires, rabble-rousers, fishermen and more. Another report mentions the roundhouse being built and the 70-foot turntable being installed in 1912. The roundhouse and turntable are clearly shown on the May 1911 revision to the July 1908 fire insurance map, with the nearby tracks denoted as Kingston & Pembroke main line, prior to the CP lease of the line:
It's also mentioned in this April, 1910 news item, mentioning its proximity to the wharf to be used for iron ore vessel loading:
Even the Duke of Connaught once frequented the roundhouse, while in Kingston to attend a ceremony at Royal Military College. His walking route on May 31, 1912, mentioning the roundhouse, was profiled in this Weekly British Whig article published on June 3 of that year:
CP's North Street yard comprised several tracks along the Cataraqui River. The tracks are empty, with passenger cars no longer in use, in this October 26, 1964 view looking toward downtown with the roundhouse and Canadian Dredge & Dock cranes and dredges in background, with a switcher's cab just visible in front of the Shell Oil tank, and CP boxcars at right. (Below - Queen's University Archives, Kingston Whig-Standard Fonds, V142.2-18)
CP’s roundhouse was demolished in 1978. The 70-foot turntable was relocated to Wakefield, QC in July, 1974. Shipped sideways in a CP 65-foot mill gondola car, a flat car was used as an idler for the overhang (below - photo from Canadian Rail, May 1976). The turntable was installed to turn CP 4-6-2 1201 (and later the 1907-built Swedish steam engine 909) on its excursions from Ottawa. 
Two Snapshot Kingston views of the CP roundhouse, turntable and yards at the foot of North Street: 1955 (one bulk tank) and 1966 (two bulk tanks):
The roundhouse was demolished in 1978. The Swamp Ward & Inner Harbour History Project has geo-located it retrospectively. Heading north from North Street, the mainline closely-paralleled the CN trackage. 

CAR SHOP ALONG MONTREAL STREET

The K&P car shop, built along Montreal Street in 1878 and shown in an 1892 fire insurance map, (above) would burn on September 12, 1905 after some years of disuse. Still standing nearby is the Depot School, designed by John Power and opened in 1873. 
The CP diverged here and crossed over the CN mainline on a bridge, superseding the 'diamond' K&P crossing of the GTR that followed the current Hagerman Lane alignment, and was deemed too dangerous. The bridge was removed at the time of CN's realignment in the early 1970s. More about this in this post on my Kingston's Hanley Spur [other] blog! From here, the K&P/CP left Kingston and headed north to serve the communities on the way to Renfrew. In the fourth and final post in this series, the stations in the southernmost communities are the focus.

KNICK-KNACKS & PARAPHERNALIA

Just as it does today, CPR 1095 is in place near CP's former passenger station on September 14, 1966 having been rolled into place and dedicated on July 1, 1966. (Below - Queen's University Archives, Kingston Whig-Standard Fonds, V142-3-244). The site was still under development - there was no show in September, despite the city sign!
My brother kindly shared this page from A Canadian History of RPOs 1853-1967  by L.F. Gillam, F.C.P.S, 1967:

A K&P advertised tender for coal in the Kingston Daily News on May 4, 1885: 

Running extra...

But what about CN? Didn't it matter, too?  You'd normally find this K&P series on my Kingston's Hanley Spur blog, but I decided to host the series here since its railway content slightly outweighed its Kingston historical content. While we're on the topic, I had the pleasure of making a presentation on both lines to the Kingston Historical Society last week. Here's the full presentation video of my PowerPoint and question period at the March 20 KHS meeting. They were great hosts!
Happy Easter to all Trackside Treasure readers! Faithful Trackside Treasure reader Terry Muirhead ventured from the Left Coast to Montreal and Niagara Falls this past week. It's nice to see someone actually riding trains, not just talking about riding trains, and in first class to boot! My photo of Terry's VIA No 60(and 50) arriving in Kingston:

and Terry's, taken while boarding VIA No 97/Amtrak No 64 at Toronto Union:

VIA Returns to the Kingston & Pembroke!

At first, when I heard about VIA planning to build its High Speed Rail (HSR) intercity line through Sharbot Lake, I didn't think much about it. Of course, the municipal government and local citizenry applauded, believing they would be a stop on the new line. The HFR scheme would seem to fit nicely with the government’s promised public-private infrastructure bank for which VIA has long been courting the highly-valued public pension funds that would comprise the core of the infrastructure investment bank.
Since then, VIA has changed the name of the project to High Frequency Rail (HFR) meaning less speed though perhaps more stops. That made more sense to me. Perhaps Sharbot Lakers had reason to celebrate. But I still thought there was not a chance in Hull that either the HSR or HFR was going to stop. In fact, VIA was already using the station code 'SFA' to refer to Sharbot Lake.

Stop the presses. Cue the humility. My loss of face was about to be Sharbot Lake's gain. Just recently, I've become aware of off-the-record information showing that not only is VIA planning to make Kingston a network hub in the HFR network, but that instead of running Ottawa trains through Brockville and Smiths Falls, that they are planning a new KPR line. Wait, KPR line? (Sharbot Lakers - start inflating the balloons - and check out the proposed KPR logo above!)

That's right, KPR = Kingston & Pembroke Rail! The line, begun by over-enthusiastic investors 150 years ago, later subsumed into the CP system, was about to have its moment in the noonday sun, far eclipsing its former role. VIA is in the preliminary early planning stages to relay track all the way north from Kingston on the former CP (Kingston & Pembroke) trackage to Sharbot Lake, connecting with the main Montreal-Ottawa-Toronto HFR line there! I'll say that again, there! This is an absolute boon for the people of Sharbot Lake, not to mention other about-to-boom former K&P communities like Murvale, Harrowsmith and Godfrey. Government funding will likely flow from the public-private infrastructure bank. You can say that again. Oh, never mind...

This map was initially released in 2017 by VIA, garnering a lot of attention at the time. But look closely! The Brockville-Ottawa line has been removed in the 2024 version, with the KPR line showing. Brockville to Ottawa is just a whole lotta white! This is eye-opening and intriguing.

VIA spokesperson Avril d'Poisson was recently interviewed on various social media outlets and Avril was the first to confirm the KPR plan. All track from the original K&P route would be relayed, she said. Much of the line is still in use as a recreational trail, and always was, since its inception a century-and-a-half ago, meandering. When asked about the numerous curves and grades on the former CP line, d'Poisson noted wryly that that would give prospective passengers more time to take in the scenic beauty of the line. What could be more recreational than that? Get to know that tree beside you, she joked. Check out the many picturesque lakes, scenic creeks and beautiful bogs. Count the turtles on the log, she said, coming out of her shell during the media scrum. The well-meaning spokesman also suggested that passengers might have time to drop a line on their journey (it was unclear whether this meant an online message to friends or family, or actual line side fishing experiences). 

Nothing succeeds like success, and Sharbot Lakers must've gotten wind of the KPR project. They are already spending their time outdoors now that springtime weather has arrived. Amazingly, crowds are seen gathering at the Railway Park along the former right-of-way, peering into the distance to be the first one in town to have the bragging rights of spotting the headlights of the approaching track laying equipment and calling out with zest, "Here she comes! Yonder comes the train!"
A note of caution, Sharbot Lakers. This is not the first time you may have had one put over on you - after all, you have a CN caboose painted CP! That aside, all that needs to be done now is the construction of a new station, and laying of new track and installation of new signals, and voila! The new line through Sharbot Lake will look much as it did in this period photo (below). Only the hemlines, the tree growth, and the name on the sign outside the Doctor's office have changed. Sharbot Lake doesn't even have the internet yet!
Word of this has not leaked to other online communities such as Glenvale, Verona and Parham, so please do not tell anyone you might know in the area. Beer-swigging street festivals, combustible bullrush-burning and even festive fish-fries will likely be quickly organized once word gets out. It will bring joy to the people. A word of caution - due to today's highly-polarized political climate, there are a fears of civil unrest when communities on the existing line get wind of this impending change. Imagine the displeasure along the current Brockville-Ottawa VIA line when it becomes obvious that VIA and its fortunes are no longer smiling on those online communities. Transport boosters and public transit advocates are also expected to trumpet the dawn of KPR and the extravagant economic eldorado that awaits. 

You heard it here first. 

Running extra...

ONT 254/255 arrived in Cochrane on March 1. The third of three new cars, ONT 253 arrived on March 21, already pre-tagged on both sides before ever taking on their first lading:

Photos posted to social media by Lloyd Leonard (above) and James Lalande (below):